Ok, first of all, you should have told her when you were together that you typically don't wear watches. I think she would have been happier to know that and would have returned the watch.
Second of all...well no, there is no second. You should have given it back to her when you decided you didnt want to wear it.
Originally Posted by INxFAMOUSxJW
the break up was just fine and we were still going to be friends and everything but she started this...
Ya you're a dick. You'll be lucky if she wants to be friends with you still.
edit - well not that it matters.