Originally Posted by foothead
Even if both were alive and fighting, Gandalf still wins.
No he does not.
Your arguments so far have been; Gandalf can call some birds, Gandalf can call some other animals, Gandalf can show Dumbledore a ring, Gandalf can set Dumbledore on fire, Gandalf can levitate Dumbledore, Gandalf can show Dumbledore some socks.
What happens in all those situations:
Dumbledore: "What is this shit?" Then he kills Gandalf.