I'd say Madden 08 looks really well on the ps3. For some reason though the controls feel delayed. Maybe its just i'm that drunk only time it gets played but its sluggish compared to the response I get on my ps2 with Madden 06. So i'd go with 06 for overall control.
this should be in the social lounge
not in hardware
mod please lock or move this thread
A lock just for having a thread in the wrong section? Give the guy a break.
@OP: I haven't played any of the Madden games so I really don't know. Check Gamespot, IGN or 1UP for reviews. I'd imagine EA hasn't changed a whole lot throughout the versions and that the older ones would be a little cheaper, but it's all personal preference.