I guess that's up to the OP to weigh. In my case, yes it would be....you are paying 10 bucks more for a better card (better rated; both are 216's) and a "free" game (which, W@W is pretty good!).
As for wolv's post, first off, the first card isn't a 216, so it's going to be cheaper. If he thinks that it's fine, by all means, he should get it. Second, the other card is recertified. It is a 216, but I like to buy things new (and I don't know the return policy on newegg if something were to go wrong with a recertified product...it might be sold "as is").
My 2 cents...
Edit: In red lettering the second card says 90 day manu. warranty...that definitely wouldn't be good enough for me. As for the OP, who knows.