Well there you have it David my friend. The question was asked and the people have spoken.
It is now up to you as to what action you take in this matter. After all the forum belongs to you. But a sage bit of advice goes something like this >
The needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few, or the one. In this case the many are your members and the one is an unwelcome outcast.
George has quickly worn out his welcome at many forums including his own. At CV he was true to form and soon wore out his welcome. When he asked to come back I based my decision on his history not only here and at CV but at other forums as well. I was not willing to bend my rules and he remains today a totally unwelcome perm banned outcast.
As I said, the people have spoken but the final decision is yours.