Eh if it plays good I don't mind. You could compare Quake4 and UT3 graphics and have a clear cut winner, but I still don't mind Q4's, even if it was a new game today, I still think it would look nice.
Ever since Half-Life2 and Doom3, I thought graphics were as good as they needed to get. I would rather have a graphically dumbed down crysis than this gorgeous one that runs at slide-show framerates on even the top of the line systems.